O2 More #JAPAN #FAIL

I've written about O2 More previously and, to be fair, have had both good and bad experiences - from being sent a Maternity wear offer and then receiving an apology, only to get then get the same message again, twice;  to receiving an MMS, with a uniquely discount voucher and the address of the nearest store to me that I could redeem it at.

Unfortunately, the day after it is announced that O2 More have hit 2 million users, this post is about one of the poor ones...

We all know what is going on over on the other side of the world right now - it feels like Armageddon over in Japan and I think we can all see that the scale of the devastation and destruction.  Given this, there are of course a number of efforts being made to raise support and money to aid the relief efforts - which should of course be applauded.  So my following criticism isn't in the act itself but, as we see way too often and from those who should know and do better, the execution of such.

So... I received an SMS from O2 More, asking me to donate.

All good there?  Well, not really.  This is from a mobile network.  A carrier, who owns the network and is responsible for all the data, voice and (relevantly in this case) messaging.  So why is the call to action not "reply" or "send a message to"?  Why have O2 not set up a premium SMS route (and waived all their fees on it)?  Surely a message such as "If you want to donate £5 to the Japan Tsunami appeal text DONATE to 20502" would allow them to to hit a broader base and illicit a greater response?

I know that this message has been delivered to by a different part of the O2 behemoth than that which would be responsible for setting up such a route but surely this is an obvious conversation to have...

Ok, so I am one of the minority of people likely to click on the link in order to donate.  What do I see?

Yeah.  I know.  And it isn't much better in landscape:

I am trying to avoid sounding churlish and criticising something that is, inherently commendable.  But I can't help thinking that it could have been so much more effective were the site that you click through to be mobile optimised and ideally allow on-bill donation.

But ultimately, it should have been an SMS mechanic - we've seen with previous appeals how effective these can be and if anyone should be doing it, O2 should.

Shouldn't they...?