I've been thinking about writing a positional piece on Mobile for a month or so now but had never got round to starting it (the closest I got was my last post which was basically about the need for marketers to consider the channel in the same way as they do others, such as email).
To be honest, the reason that I hadn't written it thus far is that I've struggled to make my up mind how to frame it. I've thought about the rousing ("It is up to us to make sure Mobile succeeds"), the industry-effacing ("If I hear someone say that this is the year of mobile again I'll....") and also the confrontational ("Why would you NOT use mobile?"). In the end, a discussion amongst some of the bods here at Movement hit the nail on the head for me. To cut a long story short, we were talking about what we as a team need to do to ensure that we're producing award-worthy work, and we discussed some of the things we have seen that are the complete antithesis of what we want to achieve. Hence the title.
In truth, all of those other statements are relevant to this - we in the industry do have a responsibility for making the channel succeed; we all know that the climate in the market right now is as conducive to success as it has ever been; and equally we all should know that Mobile is unique in its ability to operate in both isolation and (more effectively in my opinion) in conjunction with other channels - for example, it can act as the catalyst that takes a person from seeing a poster to registering an email address or visiting an online store, via a simple text-in CTA.
So, to address the title, why is there so much crap out there?!?
I am sure that most of us can think of a couple of examples of really poor uses of mobile: the iPhone app that gets 100 downloads or if it does achieve more, delivers little/no consumer benefit and is removed by the user in a week; the SMS message that links to a poorly rendered mobile site or even worse, a www site that makes no consideration for mobiles; or the nation-wide (i.e. not just London) campaign that requires the consumer to have a device with GPS and a Foursquare account.
In a recent meeting with a digital agency we were discussing a concept they had for an iPhone app and I had the temerity to suggest that a Blackberry app or, to be honest, a mobile site would be more appropriate given the regional focus and the reach and functionality that they required. Their response? "Really? But an iPhone app is so coooooooool!"*.
Dear God.
The campaign objectives were secondary to the desire to do something perceived as cool. Personally, I think that makes it anything but, so I mentioned that the only nominated activity for this years D&AD for Mobile Marketing used the extremely passé SMS (and a rather large crane of course).
That surprised them.
I've spent a bit of time being flippant about this kind of thing, making light of the fact that marketers and agencies are on the whole still struggling to 'get' mobile, but it's not something that should be made light of. If you've been in Mobile for a while now, you may remember the first dawning, back in the early days when brands were prepared to spend a bit of cash buying (purported) opt-in lists and sending push campaigns, running text-in competitions and maybe even building WAP sites. Back then Mobile was the new-kid-on-the-block and had the opportunity to break new ground, but unfortunately it only managed to get itself an ASBO. Poorly and/or dubiously executed campaigns all too often resulted in low response, high opt-out and poor RoI and, ultimately, meant that brands withdrew their cash.
Well, we're in the middle of the second dawning, and the excitement is here again.
Right now, we have all the advantages that the relentless social, cultural and technological progress of the last few years has brought us. The mobile phone has become ubiquitous; smartphone penetration is on an exponential curve; the Apple vs. Google tussle (that is dragging RIM, Nokia and Microsoft along) is driving technological advancement; and industry bodies such as the IAB are helping to further the cause.
And so it is all the more important that we don't mess it up again. You could argue that the pace of process is immutable and that mobile will become a mainstay in the marketing mix whatever. I would suggest that we're in a fairly precarious position - that the market is as fluid as it has ever been and we are not yet over the tipping point. It is important that the understanding of Mobile - how, when, why and where to use it - continues to grow. We need to keep challenging the beliefs and perceptions of both our industry peers and clients. We need to ensure that the marketing objective is always first and foremost - doing something that is perceived as cool or is award-winning with then follow naturally.
The aim should be for everyone to produce work that makes contemporaries think "I wish that I did that!", because it delivers against objectives. Nothing more. And unfortunately, there isn't enough of that out there right now. There is too much crap.
* Note: Extra o's added for effect.
Showing posts with label agency. Show all posts
Showing posts with label agency. Show all posts
Friday, 6 August 2010
Wednesday, 21 July 2010
Mobile needs to have had it's day in the sun...
Young consumers see mobiles as an extension of self. It's the one thing that they keep with them more than anything else. They use it to check Facebook first thing in the morning, personalise it with ringtones (although maybe not ringback tones) and even use it to record and share a video of their latest "happy-slapping" shenanigans.
I turned a bit Daily Mail there didn't I? Sorry.
Flippancy aside, the young get mobile. They're familiar with them and they use them.
So what about the not-so-young? Well, I'm 32 now and it's safe to say that my peers are a mixed bunch - some, like me, carry a smartphone and use it as it should be; accessing the mobile internet and using apps and exploiting features such and the camera, social-network integration and bundled services. Others are less 'sophisticated' (I use that term guardedly) - they may have a smartphone, but they use it for voice and SMS, maybe sending/receiving the odd picture message. Others carry two devices, work and home, using the work phone (e.g. a Blackberry) for email and browsing.
And what about the old? If the have a phone they tend to use it for calling and maybe a little bit of texting. My dad has an old Nokia, which still has a battery life of 2 weeks and which he won't change because he keeps the SMS and MMS that I sent him when my kids were born.
So what is the point of this gross-oversimplification of the young (mobile-savvy), not-so-young (mixed-bag) and old (mobile-luddites)?
Well initially, it leads on the question: how do marketers perceive consumers use of mobile? From there it also leads to my (bordering on scandalous) title for this post. But that will be explained in good time...
Mobile is generally still perceived as niche. Yes, it is moving more and more into the mainstream - but a glance at the budgets highlight the disparity between mobile and digital, press, TV etc. etc. Mobile is all too often still a tick-box exercise, with a small proportion of the budged hived off to be allocated to a mobile mechanic. Often, for this to be a remora of a mechanic, clinging on to the shark that is the primary activity; or worse still, a token app!
To compound this, even those in the digital world still don't understand mobile - just yesterday morning I had a conversation with a chap in the email marketing game who also offers mobile (paraphrased below - Alan Bennett I am not):
Me: We recently ran an MMS campaign, driving to an online destination, that outperformed email (shameless one-upmanship and plug all in one)
Chap: Really? We're sending an SMS push for *client*. It will push consumers onto a website.
Me: Really? What if the consumers accesses the link from their phone and not their computer.
Chap: Oh, we'll deal with that.
Me: Really? How.
Chap: Our man will make sure that it is optimised.
Now, I may be doing chap and his man a disservice, but the likes of Wapple, Volantis, MIG (Kilrush) and Netbiscuits have not spent decades of development man days and a shed-load of money on solutions that can be knocked up by his man in a week. Sure, if you were sending an email, it would be a (fairly) reasonable assumption that the user would have a device capable of rendering a microsite acceptably (I'll put aside the fact that I believe "acceptable" is simply not acceptable, and a more holistic/ cohesive/ complimentary approach, let's call it dCRM, needs to be taken to the email and mobile CRM, for now as that's another blog post entirely).
But they are not sending an email, they are sending an SMS.
Without knowledge of what device they are sending to.
So if the user does click through it'll most likely be a poor experience.
And as such, undermine the brand's message.
But what do I know?
So, why do I wish that mobile had had it's day in the sun?
Well, by definition, this would mean that it had become mainstream. It would mean that all the fuss and fan-fare had passed and mobile was considered an integral channel within a brand's marketing efforts. It would mean that brands and agencies alike "got" mobile, understanding both how consumers use it and what you can do with it; recognising it as the most personal and effective of channels - not just in it's own right, but in conjunction with all other channels.
It would mean that marketers delivered the right message, to the right person, over the right channel and in the right way.
Or at least that they should...
Or at least that they should...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)