Shamed as I am to look at the last time I wrote a blog post, I thought I'd try and get back in the groove on a topic that's been bugging me for a while.
We often talk about how mobile is uniquely positioned as, not just a channel in it's own right, but also as an integrator of channels - able to connect an offline user to a digital destination. I've blogged before about how too much activity that is talked of as "integrated" is often more like "parallel" activity with two activations running at the same time and no real integration.
However, using mobile you can engage with a consumer with a poster while they are walking down the high street; from a magazine ad they see when they are on the bus; or with a TV commercial they watch whilst sitting on their sofa, and drive them to a destination where they can get more information, register an interest or even complete a purchase.
That is a far more compelling capability than it seems to be based on the prevalence of such calls to action.
But there is an issue... There is yet to be smooth and seamless way, a completely intuitive and simple call-to-action, that enables a mobile user to respond and interact. So how do we get users to hit a URL, whether that be to visit a mobisite or download an app, for example?
Well, what have we got now? In truth, there are four credible alternatives available right now:
1. Just show the URL and ask the user to enter it themselves. One benefit of this is that the same CTA can work across desktop and mobile (assuming device redirection is in place). In addition, there is no dilution of the branding on any marketing material - the URL is often included anyway. The downside is that we are asking the user to manually type a URL, beyond the fact that this is not as easy as on a desktop (although not such a chore as it is often portrayed), it is a bit clunky and shouldn't it be easier with a smartphone?
2. Ask the user to "Search". I actually quite like this as a CTA - it's simple and familiar for users and, as with manual entry, is a consistent across desktop and mobile. That said, it forces you to ensure that your SEO is flawless and potentially require you to direct budget at search if you were not already.
3. Include an SMS shortcode/keyword CTA. Familiar for users and requires little effort, with the URL returned via SMS this is clickable and so drives the user to the destination without much fuss. That said, it's generally not liked amongst creatives for aesthetic purposes and, if a brand doesn't already run SMS activity, requires that they get this in place (that's not to say it's difficult or expensive, but it is still a barrier).
4. QR codes (or MS Tags, Shot codes etc. etc.). They have their place, and for some reason some people like them (I received an email with one in recently - ask me about it if you want a 30 min rant on the nonsensical things that some mobile companies get up to). On the plus side, they are the quickest/smoothest way of driving online from ATL. That said, this is only if you know what they are and have a reader app on your device. Oh, and they are also ugly.
So the other day it struck me, why do I have to type a URL into my mobile browser?
My phone has a camera right? Jeez, my phone can translate text so there's no reason that it couldn't recognise a URL and open the URL. So why haven't Apple or Google added it as a feature to Safari or the Android default browser? Surely they can add a button that activates the camera, recognises the text as a URL (think Google Goggles but within your browser, not a different app), and then opens the page, or even performs a search.
Am I missing something?
[Bear in mind that this is possible as it's not a webpage that accesses the camera but the browser itself, which as a native app, of course can do this.]
I may be being immensely naive but having this capability would mean that both of the routes 1 (URL) and 2 (search) above become much easier. In fact, it means that anywhere a URL may appear, it becomes 'clickable' and a call to action. Doesn't this make "integrated" activity even more feasible?
So come on Apple, get a move on Google and pull your finger out Microsoft/Nokia. Why not do this...?
Showing posts with label apple. Show all posts
Showing posts with label apple. Show all posts
Friday, 11 November 2011
Wednesday, 9 February 2011
Nokia played the fiddle while their platform burned
Ok, so I'm mixing metaphors (or something like that) but in light of Nokia CEO Stephen Elop's leaked memo to his staff (which is looking increasingly plausible by the minute) it feels very appropriate.
You can read the full memo, and the Engadget take on it, here. To save you some time, the key points that I have taken from it are:
You can read the full memo, and the Engadget take on it, here. To save you some time, the key points that I have taken from it are:
- If you're in unavoidable trouble (the "burning platform") then you need to take drastic action (jump off the platform) to avoid the inevitable peril.
- Nokia have lost the top end of the device market (mainly to Apple).
- Nokia are starting to lose the mid-range market (mainly to Google).
- Nokia are starting to be squeezed in the low end of the market too (by Eastern manufacturers).
- Nokia have historically been crap at executing.
- Nokia have ignored the way the market has evolved.
- Nokia are at "crisis point" and need to catch up and catch up very quickly.
- To catch up, Nokia need to do something 'different'.
For me to cover off all of my thoughts about Nokia, what I think of the memo and and why I think they are where they are would take an awfully long time. So I'll try not to ramble on too far - I know from reading a couple of Tomi's blogs that once you see how far down the scroll-bar on the right goes, you soon start skim reading. I'd also like to state the context of my position early on - I used to work for a Mobile Marketing and technology company, that was acquired by Nokia as part of their shift into the services space in 2007, and then worked for them for two years. So I am no Nokia expert but I certainly have an understanding of how the business works and, more importantly, how they were executing in a digital ecosystem. However, I also have no "agenda" against Nokia (as I know some ex-Nokians do). Indeed, I would much rather they succeed than fail as the market needs a credible alternative to the fast-becoming Apple/Google duopoly.
To be honest, the content of the memo is pretty damning stuff - especially considering that this is from the CEO of one of the largest, most respected, most trusted and most successful multi-national businesses out there. That it is the most read story on the BBC News website also says something about it's significance.
Unsurprisingly, ex-Nokia executive turned author, public speaker and (way too verbose - which coming from me, says something), blogger, Tomi Ahonen has had his say in a blog post that both suggests the memo is a fake and then provides a range of, primarily semantic, rebuttals to the points in Elop's memo. Ahonen's position is nothing less than symptomatic of the internal issues that Nokia has faced for a number of years. Nokia became a victim of their own success - I have talked previously about how Symbian (their proprietary operating system) was the Woolly Mammoth of operating systems, unable to adapt to the changing ecosystem. Well, for "Symbian" read "Nokia"... So I won't dwell on Ahonen's points here because, to be frank, I don't see that they are that relevant.
Nokia was the undisputed king of mobile devices with the largest market share and foothold in pretty much every market and device category. As many Nokia-philes will go to great pains to tell you, they pioneered many of the features that other manufacturers have subsequently emulated and bettered, such as mobile browsing, mobile applications and touchscreens.
And this, in itself, tells the story...
Nokia did things well, and they did them efficiently and on a large scale (they are ultimately a very good manufacturing company after all). But then they seemed to be content (dare I say arrogant?) with this position and the market evolved around them, not least catalysed by the growth of the digital channel in general and the emergence of the iPhone. Nokia's response was to try and move with the market, but to do so in a way that was poorly judged and poorly executed - their higher-end devices were roundly criticised and their ecosystem (Ovi and services) was a hotch-potch of acquisitions and (often duplicated or competing) internal development projects all shoved together with (apparently) little strategic thought. But that was just the top-end of the market, Nokia could still rely on the mid and lower end (such as emerging markets) couldn't they?
Uh oh...
They could... but of course those markets changed too. And Nokia (apparently) still refused to see what most people outside of the business have seen for a while. Nokia became like King Canute, convinced that they could hold back the inevitable tide. Until they did away with their previous CEO, Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo, and brought in ex-Microsoft man Stephen Elop. The significance of this is that they recruited from the outside rather than, as was usually the case previously, internally. Now it seems that the fresh pair of eyes, directed internally, is starting to realise that significant action is needed in order to get Nokia back into it's stride.
And so what should they do and how can they address this?
Well, there have been persistent rumours that Nokia will buddy up with Microsoft (Elop is ex-Microsoft after all) and run Windows Phone 7 in some of its devices. Whether that is instead of, or alongside, Maemo and Symbian remains to be seen (indeed, the WP7 thing is still only a rumour of course). There has also been talk about Nokia partnering with Google to run Android in their devices instead but I don't even see this as a starter to be honest - there are too many areas in which Nokia and Android compete, not least with mapping (i.e. Nokia Maps vs. Google Maps), that there would be undoubted friction in such a relationship. After all, services, and the advertising running on them, is where the money is. That is not so say that there isn't overlap with WP7, it's just that Microsoft also seems prepared to compromise given its need to re-gain a foothold in the market (witness the partnership with Yahoo for search). Perhaps the two, much-maligned, former-behemoths would form a formidable partnership, capable of competing with Apple, Google and the plethora of mid/lower-range competitors in the mobile space. Only time will tell if it even happens and whether, if it does, it will be a success, although Google's VP of Engineering seems relatively unconcerned with the prospect, tweeting "Two turkeys do not make an eagle", as reported by Ewan at MIR.
One thing is for sure, the entire market seems to be waiting with baited breath for an announcement that is reportedly due on Friday and whatever other news comes out at Mobile World Congress next week.
And we thought 2010 was an exciting year, jeez 2011 is getting interesting already...
Labels:
android,
apple,
featurephone,
google,
microsoft,
mobile,
nokia,
smartphone,
WP7
Thursday, 23 December 2010
2010: The Year (in Mobile) That Was Part 1 - The Smartphone Race
If I had a pound for every time that I heard someone say "if I had a pound every time someone said that this is the year of mobile, I'd be a rich man", I'd be a rich man... Denying that there was, or will be, or even should be, a "Year of Mobile" has become more annoying to me than claiming that any given year was it. So given that, I will try and phrase the following very carefully:
2010 has been a year in which we have seen an unprecedented growth and evolution of the mobile market. In the last 12 months, we have seen record and increasing spend within the mobile channel as well as a slew of brands executing campaigns with an, often tactical rather than strategic, mobile element. Record display and search spending and the increasing visibility of mobile above-the-line and use of it as a below-the-line comms channel, facilitated by the pace of development of mobile technology and the consumer uptake of this, mean that Mobile is as prominent as it has ever been.
Compared to the wider digital channel, Mobile still needs to be considered as an emerging medium, if only in terms of spend, but the increasing penetration of mobile into every part of our everyday life mean that it holds a unique position. It is not just an ethereal channel such as a Social Network – in part it is a physical device, with a tactile interface, meaning that user experience is more than just a site map or user journey; and it is more than a piece of hardware used to access content – consumers carry it almost all the time; it is often the first and last thing that people look at each day; and it is used for communicating, browsing, engaging with a Social Network, playing games, finding a location and navigating to it, redeeming coupons or voucher and increasingly for making purchases.
So it is in this context, and with 2010 nearing its end, that I have taken a (UK focussed) look at some of the important events that in my opinion have occurred in the last 12 months and helped to shape and define the market in 2010 and beyond. In further posts, I’ll look at how 2010 saw technology develop and brand/agency adoption increase, and what I think may happen in 2011 and beyond but this first post will focus on what is probably the most eagerly fought and exciting area of the market: smartphones.
The smartphone race
Although some commentators may say that the smartphone has been around for many years, the reality of it is that the early Nokia N-series devices such as the N70 and N95 would not go many rounds against their modern day descendents. Perhaps we should consider these the missing-link of the mobile device world – the phones that bridged the gap between those that were used only for voice, SMS, maybe some MMS and more rarely a bit of WAP browsing, and the current mini-computers-with-voice-and-messaging that are achieving increasing market penetration. In that case, Nokia does deserve some credit (don’t worry, I’ll make up for that later) but in truth, as I’ve mentioned before, the major catalyst of the smartphone era is undoubtedly the iPhone. Its first incarnation had significant limitations and is very different from the current iPhone 4, but its impact on the market is undeniable. The smartphone market is increasingly where the consumers, brands, developers and, most significantly, margins exist. And so it is this battleground that is so keenly fought over (notably from all directions like a game of Risk) by the carriers, device manufacturers and OS/service providers (I’m mainly thinking about Google here of course) – and where some companies occupy more than one of these roles.
So what has happened then? Well, where to start......?
1. The iPhone 4 and iPad was released
The original iPhone was released back in 2007 and, as I’ve mentioned, redefined the smartphone paradigm in such as way that it took until this year for its competitors to really get into a position where some of them could argue that that they are truly competitive.
I’ve commented about the release of both the iPhone 4 and iPad previously so won’t dwell on that here, but as far as the iPhone 4 is concerned, although iOS had been through a couple of updates, by this year the hardware was in need of a refresh and boy does the iPhone 4 look and feel good. My main worry about the iPhone is that now, as they are undeniably being caught-up by competitors, there is a need for iOS to be updated or they risk being left with an outdated UI. Will this be one of the stories of 2011?
As for the iPad, Apple are again redefining the rules of the game. As I’ve said, they haven’t targeted an under-exploited market opportunity with the iPad, they’ve created one - a beautiful, portable, touchscreen device for the consumption (and enjoyment) of content. This time round, however, the competition are already on the case and a following swiftly – they do not want to be left standing as they did with the iPhone.
2. Android achieved critical (and competitive) mass
Probably the most credible competition to Apple comes in the form of Google’s Android operating system. They have taken a different tack to Apple in that the OS is to a certain extent device-agnostic. This has seen a number of traditional feature-phone manufacturers (e.g. Samsung and Sony Ericsson) and emerging players (e.g. HTC) focus on producing a device and allow Google to ship their OS and, of course, services (I still find it fascinating that the strategy behind an entire OS and mobile services (such as Goggles, Translate etc.) is so finely focussed on one thing – advertising revenue). This means that Android does not solely focus on the high-end smartphone market alongside the iPhone, but reaches the mid- and lower-tier smartphone markets and in doing so addresses a larger (and typically less tech-savvy) market. Their market share (UK/all devices) as shown by comScore rose from 0.7% in Jan 2010 to 4.3% in Oct 2010*, that's a x6 rise (for reference, in that same period iPhone penetration increased from 4.7% to 8.8% and Blackberry from 4.7% to 5.2%, whilst both Windows and Symbian suffered reduced market share*).
2010 has seen the number and, importantly, the quality of apps in the Android Marketplace rise. They are still way behind the App Store, and the iPhone is still the default option for a mobile app in the majority of cases but the comparative ease of deploying an Android app and the broader nature of the market that can be addressed make it an increasingly viable option.
3. Nokia failed again to produce worthy smartphone
As I mentioned above, Nokia can probably be credited with producing the first ‘recognised’ smartphone. However, also as I’ve mentioned, Symbian (the “Woolly Mammoth of operating systems”) has lost market share. There is an argument that Nokia knows exactly what it is doing and is executing its smartphone strategy very well. Unfortunately this argument somehow fails to recognise the obvious truth – that Nokia is in no small amount of turmoil. With a change of CEO and followed by a number of other high profile departures, including the EVP and Head of their Mobile Solutions business and the Chief of MeeGo (their fabled new Linux-based OS in joint partnership with Intel), and their market share and profits in decline, I cannot imagine a great amount of cheer at their Board’s Christmas party this year.
Nokia cannot be compared directly with their traditional feature phone competitors, not just because of the scale and breadth of their operation but because of the position that they are trying to move themselves into. Equally, they cannot really be compared to Apple or Google as, again, their positioning and focus is different. And so they need to be considered solely on their results and forecasts based on current position and strategy.
They are trying to utilise their significant market share (across all devices) to drive uptake of their smartphones, and in doing so driving use of, and revenue from, their services. Put simply, the money to be made a manufacturer is limited - you need large volumes to deliver this given the low margins. Nokia has that scale, but the opportunity for growth in a saturated market of which they already had the major market share is negligible and in an increasingly smartphone focussed market, this would only be eroded.
But the smartphone market does bring opportunity if you can either focus on the high end (low volume, high margin) like Apple or services (i.e. advertising) like Google. So this is where Nokia want to be, whilst not neglecting the still-massive feature phone market (hence their restructuring of the business to separate and distinct units).
But they’re failing.
The N8 was supposed to be their break-though device that re-established them as a serious contender. Unfortunately it suffered from similar issues as its predecessors such as the N97: the hardware, although not in the same class as the iPhone, is strong; the device capabilities are also good; and, although it suffers from too few quality apps and too much content, the Ovi store is nicely integrated given the need to support so many devices in so many markets.
The issue is the operating system and the UI that is presents. Unfortunately Symbian is not up to the job of supporting a modern smartphone and Symbian ^3 is, if you pardon the expression, just the latest polishing of that turd**.
Release of their latest device, the E7, which is basically an N8 with a slide-out keyboard has been delayed until next year, capping a dreadful year for what was only a few years ago (and in many ways still is) one of the most respected, trusted and admired brands.
In my opinion, Nokia needs to take a leaf out of Microsoft’s book and start from scratch. Now that may be what they are doing with MeeGo but if the N900 (running Maemo) is anything to go by then Nokia haven’t yet learnt that they need to understand what users want and then deliver it. It unfortunately feels like many of the decisions that they make are based on false or incorrect premises and (I can say this having worked in the business for over a year) are hindered by the time it takes internally to both make a decision and then execute on it. I want Nokia to succeed. The market could do with a European business in the upper-echelons. I’m sure that they can, but I’m not really convinced that they will...
4. Windows Phone 7 was released
I have a confession - having owned a Palm Treo back in 2007, I actually quite liked Windows Mobile. The only possible explanation that I can find for this (you may consider this a convenient bit of post-rationalisation) is that it was a familiar interface. Having always been a Windows desktop owner, and wanting to browse and use email from my device, it was one of the few viable options. As a phone it was awful and the OS wasn’t great – but I kinda liked it.
That said, I was in a very small minority.
And so, following rounded criticism of their latest upgrade/release, Windows Mobile 6.5, Microsoft took the approach of starting from scratch with Windows Phone 7 (WP7). It could be said that 6.5 was very much a compromise, trying to appear to be in the game and fill some of the inevitable void caused by the revamp. In any event, 2010 has seen WP7 launched to general approval. There was not necessarily whooping from the rooftops but Microsoft is never going to generate that kind of fervour is it? It is not a perfect mobile OS and there are certinaly improvements that can be made, but there are similarly some nice features such as the live tiles, a smart look & feel, XBox Live integration and Silverlight support meaning app development is a smooth process.
Given the years of monopoly/duopoly in the smartphone space (ok a triumvirate if you include Blackberry), it is at least good to see a credible alternative from Microsoft that I hope will evolve in the coming months. It will no doubt take time for the industry to come on board but, as do Apple and Google, Microsoft see mobile as a key plank in their future strategy and so they will certainly be putting their effort behind it. And consumer uptake should grow, recent reports of 1.5 million being “shipped” should not be confused with “sales”, but are a relatively good sign nonetheless.
The good news for us all is that in any such market with competition amongst a number of serious players, innovation and capabilities are driven upwards whilst prices are driven in the other direction. I hope...
5. Blackberry shifted focus towards the consumer market
Given all the other moving and shaking that has gone on elsewhere, you could think that it’s been a quiet year for RIM but that isn’t really the case. Their UK market share remained pretty flat, but their year has been marked by challenges in international markets regarding the access to the encrypted transmissions sent via their Messenger (BBM) and email services, and a change of approach to move away from their comfort-zone of the Enterprise market to focus on the consumer market.
Blackberrys have been the business device of choice for a number of years. Whilst other manufacturers have made some inroads, and will probably continue to do so with Exchange integration via ActiveSync so straight-forward, the security controls that RIM has created around communications via/from/to their devices mean that for many large corporates, it is the only real option. This encryption has caused some issues with a number of Nations (such as Saudi Arabia) wanting to gain access to the details of and, in some cases, the content of communications for National Security reasons. Such issues rarely come to head as there is always a solution to be found but I don’t doubt that some headaches have been and will continue to be felt at BB Towers for a while.
However, more interesting to me is the way in which, seemingly almost by accident, Blackberrys became a device of choice for the younger generation of mobile owner. Blackberry Messenger (BBM) is an instant messaging/chat functionality in their devices that is free to users. Given this, it’s easy to see why it gained traction with younger users. This gave RIM a nice challenge to make their devices, pricing and marketing more consumer focussed – one that they addressed this year. Their devices certainly still have issues: the browser, for example, is in real need of improvement and the available apps are lagging well behind.
But you can’t argue that they typically occupy a top-3 position in the smartphone market, and so have to be considered – probably more than they usually are...
What it all means
Well, it means that next year will be exciting. There is still a lot to play for and whilst my next post will look at other activity in the world of Mobile in 2010 (such as the technological developments and agency/brand uptake of the medium) I will also, probably in the New Year, have a look at the future of the eco-system in 2011 and beyond and you can be sure that the smartphone arena will be a massive part of this.
** Please note that I think Symbian is without doubt the OS of choice for feature phones
Labels:
2010,
android,
apple,
blackberry,
mobile,
nokia,
smartphone,
tablet,
WP7
Wednesday, 9 June 2010
iPhone 4. What's it all about then?
For those who are not aware - and I think that many of us in London-centric digital-land (myself included) sometimes forget that not everyone is on the pulse of the latest breaking trends; some people aren't minutely aware of the raging smartphone war; some think that an iPad is a sanitary product; and, dare I say it, there are even people who haven't a clue what Twitter and Foursquare are - on Monday (the 7th June) at Apple’s annual World Developers’ Conference in San Francisco, Apple CEO Steve Jobs unveiled the new iPhone 4.
What's the iPhone 4 got then?
Not wanting to miss the boat as per usual, this blog post is my take on the new device (after all it is far more than a phone), its release and my initial thoughts about what it means for the industry and consumers. However, to start with, here's a typically schmaltzy video espousing the virtues of the new device (if you can't be bothered with sticking about for over 6 mins, you can skip it as I'll give a brief synopsis below):
I'll talk about what I see as a couple of the main features (of both the device and the new iOS 4, announced previously and which also runs on the iPad and will be available for compatible 3G, 3GS and iPod Touch models) a bit later on but a quick run of the salient points is:
- Small but perfectly formed - 24% thinner that the last iPhone and flat backed so a more 'comfortable' device to pocket and leave on a desk - the device looks really nice and, by all accounts, the build quality is superior to anything else (Vertu excepted maybe) on the market;
- Top notch display - the "Retina Display" delivers 300px per sq. inch and looks really (seriously, really!) sharp;
- 2 noise cancellation mics - should help with voice recognition and call quality;
- 5 megapixel rear-facing camera with LED flash - nothing particularly ground-breaking here but something that they really needed to improve based on competitor offerings;
- FaceTime - Apple's attempt at re-inventing video calling. More on this later...;
- Front-facing camera - in order to support video calling;
- HD video capture and iMovie - video editing capabilities (it'll be interesting to see how much this is actually used although it does look good);
- Multi-tasking - (one of) my biggest criticisms of previous versions has been the lack of multi-tasking so it was great (albeit expected) when this was announced with iOS4 previously;
- Improved file management - allowing the arrangement of your apps into folders;
- Improved email inbox management - another of my criticisms was the painful process for switching between email accounts, this has been addressed with a shared inbox and threading of messages;
- Improved battery life - apparently giving 7hrs talk time and 6hrs 3G browsing (10hrs on WiFi). Battery life is a bugbear of mine so this is a nice improvement although it remains to be seen how this stands up in the real world and what effect apps and multi-tasking will have on this;
- Gyroscope - not just tracking the pitch (front-to-back) and roll (side-to-side tilting) of the device, but also the yaw (side-to-side rotation). Integrating this into games and applications as well as advertising has the possibility of greatly enriching the users gesture feedback as the Wii did for gaming; and
- iAds - Apple's rich mobile advertising format has the potential to help force the pace of mobile advertising growth, again, more in this a bit later...
Basically, nothing significant that we didn't already know on the basis of previous releases, leaks and losses but it's still exciting to see the typical Apple razzmatazz and the way that they package these features - and not forgetting the usual media response and comment...
Surprisingly (not least for me) Apple have departed from the norm of an initial US-only launch and will be releasing the iPhone 4 both in the UK and US, later this month on the 24th June. There is no news on UK pricing but in the US they are shipping at $199 for the 16Gb version and $299 for 32Gb. Given previous experience I would expect them being a touch more pricey over here but maybe, given that there is no carrier-exclusivity here anymore, the competition may keep the prices low. The expected four will be carrying the iPhone 4 and my studious monitoring of their Twitter feeds caught their announcements:
O2 were unsurprisingly first out of the blocks at 20:03 on Monday evening, with a link to their pre-registration page and also mentioned a limited-time special upgrade offer for in-contract customers;
Orange were next up at 21:29 that evening also, the ever friendly Conor directed followers to the Orange pre-registration page where you can sign of for further updates;
Vodafone didn't manage to beat my arbitrarily imposed (and pretty irrelevant) midnight deadline by tweeting their announcement at 00:07 on the 8th. Again, followers were directed to a pre-registration page;
And so T-Mobile were the last risers, not getting their Twitter announcement out until 15:16 on the 8th (indeed Conor from their new bed-fellows Orange actually beat them to the punch by a few minutes). T-Mobile seem to not be taking pre-registrations and instead directed followers to their media centre for updates - not the best user experience it has to be said...
So what are the important bits?
There's plenty that can be talked about from the list above but, in my opinion at least, there are a couple that are worth some real attention based on their potential for further changing the market - FaceTime and iAds...
Wasn't video calling a damp squib last time round?
You could say that (he says, entering into a cyber-space conversation with himself - that's got to be a bad sign. Almost as bad as psycho-analysing yourself in cyber-space, he replied....)!
I'm sure that I'm not the only person who remembers the launch of the new carrier 3 back in 2003 and the adverts heralding the advent of a new era of mobile video calls. Well, it never happened. Whether due to call quality, high cost, poor user experience or the lack of someone to call who also had a capable phone (which reminds me of the question - who did Alexander Graham Bell call when he invented the first telephone?), consumers refused to take it up and so video calling has remained restricted to enterprise (and more relevantly non-mobile) application since.
Could FaceTime change that?
We've seen before that Apple leads the way in delivering top quality user experience and products and services that people simply want to use. As a mate (and fellow mobilist) Murat recently tweeted:
"Yeah video calling has been around for ages but so had phones, experiences rules - if it's slick it'll give video calling the kiss of life"
On the basis of the Apple video above and the review from CNet below, both the user experience and the quality (aided by FaceTime initially only being available over a WiFi connection) look pretty damn good:
So that leaves the cost and having someone to call.
The cost front is covered initially because of FaceTime only running over WiFi from launch. But even once this restriction is relaxed and you are able to make video calls over a 3G (or in time LTE/4G connection) with the near-ubiquity of data bundles, particularly with iPhone and other smartphone calling plans, this shouldn't be an issue at all. The only caveat that I will add to this (and it applies to the call quality also) is that the carriers bear a significant responsibility here - both in terms of the network quality and also in relation to the application of the usual "fair usage policy" applied to all-you-can-eat data plans. If they mess this up, there is little that Apple can do...
And finally there is the "who to call" question. Well, there are an awful lot of iPhone users out there and you can be sure that a good proportion of them will upgrade to the iPhone 4 over the coming months. However, from launch, FaceTime will only be possible from iPhone 4 to iPhone 4. It will not be available on the 3G/3GS or other devices, which does significantly restrict the possible number of calls that can be made. But it looks like it IS the intention to widen the distribution of FaceTime as an open industry standard. This is the kicker as I see it - if Apple allows other manufacturers to implement FaceTime functionality into their devices there will be no barrier to uptake - I can call my iPhone 4 owning friend from my HTC running Android. It is a massive "if" (particularly given all the recent patent disputes between rival manufacturers) but IF this happens, there should be no real reason for video calling not to become more popular. It will never replace voice calling, we shouldn't expect that, but it could become a viable, accepted and consumer adopted calling option.
What does iAds do for mobile advertising and marketing?
To address this, I'll start with the killer stat - Mary Meeker of Morgan Stanley (who knows a thing or two about the digital landscape having previously been dubbed the “Queen of the Net”) predicts that mobile web users will be overtaking desktop within 5 years:

However, although mobile advertising spend continues to increase (as shown in a recent IAB and PwC study) there is still a disparity between the number of users of the mobile internet and the relative mobile advertising spend, in comparison to online. The possible reasons for this are legion, ranging from brands acceptance of mobile as a channel to the creative restrictions of the current MMA guidelines.
Whatever the actual reason(s) may be, Apple and the other traditional big players, such as Google and Microsoft, are certainly turning their attention to the channel as recent acquisitions and comments have made clear. So with Apple also announcing that they already have $60 million in advertiser commitments in 2010 for iAds (the advertising, served by Apple into apps running on the iPhone, iPad and iPod Touch), from brands such as Unilever, AT&T, Chanel and Walt Disney, including one (or more) that has had to stump up $10M to be the first advertiser, there is certainly no lack of brand focus. This may be centred on iAds, but the wider mobile advertising eco-system can only benefit from this.
Additionally, the richer creative and improved user experience that iAds offer should serve as a benchmark across the industry. To reference Murat again, he has blogged about the need for industry guidelines to evolve in-line with device capabilities. This have never been more the case than now, as the iPhone dragged smartphone capabilities on its coat tails, so should iAds do the same for mobile advertising - and with the increasing penetration of HTML5 support into mobile browsers, the kind of functionality that was only possible within an app can be exploited within a browser context, meaning the richer experience advertising can be available across devices and it is up to us in the industry to ensure that this is the case!
Which all means...?
The iPhone 4 isn't a revolutionary or game changing device in the way that its predecessors were. The smartphone market has caught up enough in the last year or so that the competitors are at least on the same lap of the race. However, the iPhone 4 has certainly given Apple a burst of speed down the back-straight and pushed them further ahead. You can be sure that the competition will kick on and respond, and in some areas they remain ahead (device customisation and "cloud" integration for example), but by pushing into "new" ground and forcing the market onwards, Apple continues to be the major catalyst for the progression of the industry.
Will I be getting an iPhone 4? Probably not, no. Do I think that it'll be the best device on the market? Yes, I probably do...
Thursday, 3 June 2010
What's the point of the iPad?
Apple have sold 2 million iPads in two months (is it even meaningful to mention that this is over 30,000 a day?) and predictions are that they will top 10 million by the end of this year.
Coincidentally, I saw my first iPad advert on the TV last night and was also dragged into a debate about the relative merits of the iPad on the train into London this morning. Unusually for me, given my dogged (I would say pragmatic) refusal to fall in line with the Apple hype-factory following, I was taking a pro-iPad stance...
This brought to mind some conversations and thoughts that I have had previously about the iPad. Basically, the question that has been on my mind for a while has been what, exactly, is the point of the iPad? Once you get beyond the social-media hype that Apple consistently manage to stir up around their product launches, who is going to use the iPad? And why?
Apple never fail to disappoint when it comes to whipping up a maelstrom of media frenzy in the months preceding a launch; with rumour, leaks and press exclusives satiating the demand of the Apple-adoring public. Indeed, the irony of Steve Jobs' recent comment about Bloggers was not lost on me for one... And so it happened with the iPad - months of speculation about the name, let-alone the features and functionality of the device, generated an amount of interest previously unheard of.
The demand for a tablet device was born.
But irrespective of Apple's success at creating demand, my question is still unanswered. Just what is the point of the iPad?
Well, I can tell you for one that it doesn't replace the iPhone (or any mobile device for that matter) - it's just too big for that. Apple may extol the virtues of it being a portable device but, unless you're going to put it in a bag, you're not going to carry it around too far. Additionally, without voice capabilities (although the more expensive versions will have 3G for data connectivity) it won't replace many of the uses of the smartphone. Indeed, debate rages about whether the iPad should be regarded as a mobile device - for search, Google do regard it as such so that may be the trump card in that debate, but in general (digital) terms I think it should probably not be.
And so on the other side of the spectrum in terms of the market, sits the Netbook and beyond that, the Laptop and PC/Mac. There is a good argument that these guys will be the main casualty to the iPad. What would you be more likely to do - get out a netbook or a tablet to have a quick browse when you're sat at home. I certainly know what I would prefer to do.
There's no denying that Apple make really nice devices and that in terms of user experience they have few rivals, but the iPad will never replace their more powerful cousins - you won't be able to check your email, browse the internet and work on a document on the iPad. So let me try and answer my own question:
The iPad has created, or at the very least brought to the mainstream, a new genre of technology.
The iPad is not about doing things like smartphones and 'standard' computers (by that I mean netbooks, laptops and PC/Macs). You typically use these devices as a means-to-an-end; to meet an objective; to create something; or to manage multiple tasks at once. They are tools.
I don't see the iPad as a tool. It's a conduit, for the consumption of media. Sure you'll use it to play games, but aimless games in the way you do on an iPhone to kill time, not like you do an a Playstation or even a PSP. It's primary use will be for browsing the internet; reading books and magazines; and watching video. So the real casualty is likely to be the more 'traditional' tools - books, magazines and TV, this is what the iPad replaces as it creates a new paradigm in the use of technology.
And you can rest assured that there will be a raft of similar (albeit less useable) devices over the coming months. I would be certain that the smooth-and-sleek tablet band wagon will be jumped on by a number of manufacturers that can produce the hardware cheaper, bundle it with Android, or similar open-source operating system - meaning that the tablet is not restricted to those with cash to burn as the iPhone was for so long. In fact, it's already happening.
So I'm drawn back to my original question: What's the point of the iPad? My answer?
The point is progress. It's about people doing the same things but in a new way. And whether you like it or not, you certainly can't stop it...
Coincidentally, I saw my first iPad advert on the TV last night and was also dragged into a debate about the relative merits of the iPad on the train into London this morning. Unusually for me, given my dogged (I would say pragmatic) refusal to fall in line with the Apple hype-factory following, I was taking a pro-iPad stance...
This brought to mind some conversations and thoughts that I have had previously about the iPad. Basically, the question that has been on my mind for a while has been what, exactly, is the point of the iPad? Once you get beyond the social-media hype that Apple consistently manage to stir up around their product launches, who is going to use the iPad? And why?
Apple never fail to disappoint when it comes to whipping up a maelstrom of media frenzy in the months preceding a launch; with rumour, leaks and press exclusives satiating the demand of the Apple-adoring public. Indeed, the irony of Steve Jobs' recent comment about Bloggers was not lost on me for one... And so it happened with the iPad - months of speculation about the name, let-alone the features and functionality of the device, generated an amount of interest previously unheard of.
The demand for a tablet device was born.
But irrespective of Apple's success at creating demand, my question is still unanswered. Just what is the point of the iPad?
Well, I can tell you for one that it doesn't replace the iPhone (or any mobile device for that matter) - it's just too big for that. Apple may extol the virtues of it being a portable device but, unless you're going to put it in a bag, you're not going to carry it around too far. Additionally, without voice capabilities (although the more expensive versions will have 3G for data connectivity) it won't replace many of the uses of the smartphone. Indeed, debate rages about whether the iPad should be regarded as a mobile device - for search, Google do regard it as such so that may be the trump card in that debate, but in general (digital) terms I think it should probably not be.
And so on the other side of the spectrum in terms of the market, sits the Netbook and beyond that, the Laptop and PC/Mac. There is a good argument that these guys will be the main casualty to the iPad. What would you be more likely to do - get out a netbook or a tablet to have a quick browse when you're sat at home. I certainly know what I would prefer to do.
There's no denying that Apple make really nice devices and that in terms of user experience they have few rivals, but the iPad will never replace their more powerful cousins - you won't be able to check your email, browse the internet and work on a document on the iPad. So let me try and answer my own question:
The iPad has created, or at the very least brought to the mainstream, a new genre of technology.
The iPad is not about doing things like smartphones and 'standard' computers (by that I mean netbooks, laptops and PC/Macs). You typically use these devices as a means-to-an-end; to meet an objective; to create something; or to manage multiple tasks at once. They are tools.
I don't see the iPad as a tool. It's a conduit, for the consumption of media. Sure you'll use it to play games, but aimless games in the way you do on an iPhone to kill time, not like you do an a Playstation or even a PSP. It's primary use will be for browsing the internet; reading books and magazines; and watching video. So the real casualty is likely to be the more 'traditional' tools - books, magazines and TV, this is what the iPad replaces as it creates a new paradigm in the use of technology.
And you can rest assured that there will be a raft of similar (albeit less useable) devices over the coming months. I would be certain that the smooth-and-sleek tablet band wagon will be jumped on by a number of manufacturers that can produce the hardware cheaper, bundle it with Android, or similar open-source operating system - meaning that the tablet is not restricted to those with cash to burn as the iPhone was for so long. In fact, it's already happening.
So I'm drawn back to my original question: What's the point of the iPad? My answer?
The point is progress. It's about people doing the same things but in a new way. And whether you like it or not, you certainly can't stop it...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

